ArtworkHey Arnold!
Chapter 1
It's your call. The story carries on the same way whether you kill or spare Arnold.
Sparing him counts toward a Restrained criminal profile. Killing him counts toward Hardened.
If you spare him, Arnold sends Jason $10,000 as a thank-you later in the game.
Chapter
1
Spare
Restrained, $10,000 later
Kill
Hardened